Check These Out: Buddy Finder | Videos | SpouseBUZZ | My Friend Network | News | Military Equipment


Military.com    Military.com Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  Marine Corps Discussions  Hop To Forums  USMC Infantry    Anyone back from al Qaim,Iraq 2007
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
  Login/Join 
Basic Training
Posted
I first of all would like to thank you for serving.I'm not sure if this is cool or not but I have a few questions about being there. I have a stepson in 3/2 marines. He is telling ,via email,friends of his about waxing mfers and terrorists sneaking in the wire things that if he truly went through I didn't think a marine would talk about to civilians. The reason I question his conduct is he has told people in the past that he was a scout sniper working with the CIA.Pretty amazing 4 months after recruit training. Also do most marines take to heart the whole marine honor integrity motto? He is coming back from Iraq next week.
 
Posts: 2 | Registered: Wed 07 May 2008Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
3/2 relieved my unit several monthes ago. Before that they were one of our adjacent units. At that time there wasn't to much activity, definitly nothing like what your stepson seems to be hinting at. I spent a lot of time in that AO and talked to a lot of 3/2 Marines, and I would say theres a very good chance your stepson is making **** up.


Note: With the cut back of the surge, battalions are being scattered like a mother****er all across Al Anbar to fill in the holes, so its possible your stepson was on a MIT team or something, 100 miles from 3/2s main body.
 
Posts: 55 | Registered: Sun 02 September 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Picture of AHill_USMC
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Ignoranceisbliss:
Note: With the cut back of the surge, battalions are being scattered like a mother****er all across Al Anbar to fill in the holes, so its possible your stepson was on a MIT team or something, 100 miles from 3/2s main body.


I know, I was horrified when 1/9 showed up in Ramadi to releave us AND 2/8. One Battalion for the entire city of Ramadi. But it has to happen eventually.
 
Posts: 1686 | Registered: Sat 21 May 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by 10713106:
I first of all would like to thank you for serving.I'm not sure if this is cool or not but I have a few questions about being there. I have a stepson in 3/2 marines. He is telling ,via email,friends of his about waxing mfers and terrorists sneaking in the wire things that if he truly went through I didn't think a marine would talk about to civilians. The reason I question his conduct is he has told people in the past that he was a scout sniper working with the CIA.Pretty amazing 4 months after recruit training. Also do most marines take to heart the whole marine honor integrity motto? He is coming back from Iraq next week.

My battalion was in Al-Qaim from March to October last year and the city wasn't even close to being that active. My company was detached from my battalion so I didn't operate in AQ myself....but the other companies saw next to nothing.

My AO was fairly active with "incidents" nearly every week, but guys sneaking through the wire and stuff like that? Get real. Roll Eyes
 
Posts: 441 | Registered: Sun 08 January 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Basic Training
Posted Hide Post
Wow, a stepdad who comes on a Marine forum just to do integrity checks on his deployed Marine stepson.
That's um, motivated.

Maybe you should try thanking your son for his service instead of thanking us, and leave the scouting and sniping up to him.

BTW, what's his name? I'de like to look him up on global and write him an email. He deserves a warm welcome back home.
 
Posts: 28 | Registered: Tue 06 May 2008Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Basic Training
Posted Hide Post
The army rejected this guy for lying on his application he and his father filled out with the recruiter.I thought there was no way the few and the proud would accept him but they did.I was asking because his mother thinks the marines may change his pathological lying but I don't think it has.I also thought that the true Marines would give answers to my questions because they would not want to be lumped in with a wanna be Rambo lying about making kills. I don't treat him like shiite or anything it's just that I have quite a few friends kids and my own relatives that have gone to Iraq that I feel he is disrespecting everyone of them that have served honorably. He will be welcomed back because even if he is an ahole his my wifes son.

This message has been edited. Last edited by: 10713106,
 
Posts: 2 | Registered: Wed 07 May 2008Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
He didn't accuse his stepson of anything, so I don't see the need to jump this guy's case. Besides, it sounds like this Marine is full of **** anyway. If he's in Al-Qaim, I'd bet everything I own this kid hasn't pulled a trigger let alone anything remotely close to the stories he seems to be telling. Telling bogus warstories isn't very respectable to me.
 
Posts: 441 | Registered: Sun 08 January 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Basic Training
Posted Hide Post
Of course his tall tales aren't respectable, and his exagerations are like fishing stories. I never said he was telling the whole truth, that wasn't the point.
The point was- regardless of whether or not he has ever pulled the trigger and his exaggerated stories, he still deserves a certain amount of gratitude and respect just for being a Marine, deployed- out there defending perhaps a slightly more honests american ability to sit on the couch and watch american idol.
Most grunts I know are quite dissapointed when they come to face the fact that they don't get the opprotunity to do what they or america expects them to, and a few exaggerate to compensate. Is that right? NO. But if you're not out there, you should be so damned grateful that he did any kind of deployment for you, and happy he's just coming home in one piece.
 
Posts: 28 | Registered: Tue 06 May 2008Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Picture of kjjm
Posted Hide Post
We patrolled Al Quaim in 2006 and lost guys to IEDs .
That can be a weird neighborhood on the right day.
His stories sound a little far fetched
 
Posts: 620 | Registered: Sun 10 August 2003Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by anywherealwaysready:
Of course his tall tales aren't respectable, and his exagerations are like fishing stories. I never said he was telling the whole truth, that wasn't the point.
The point was- regardless of whether or not he has ever pulled the trigger and his exaggerated stories, he still deserves a certain amount of gratitude and respect just for being a Marine, deployed- out there defending perhaps a slightly more honests american ability to sit on the couch and watch american idol.
Most grunts I know are quite dissapointed when they come to face the fact that they don't get the opprotunity to do what they or america expects them to, and a few exaggerate to compensate. Is that right? NO. But if you're not out there, you should be so damned grateful that he did any kind of deployment for you, and happy he's just coming home in one piece.



I do not agree. But that aside...this wouldn't be the Rachel I know from 1/6 i think it was? Or maybe 2/2? The Rachel I know through eric peterson sgt type.

if it is what's goin on man?
 
Posts: 89 | Registered: Fri 30 March 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Basic Training
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by followmetolive:
quote:
Originally posted by anywherealwaysready:
Of course his tall tales aren't respectable, and his exagerations are like fishing stories. I never said he was telling the whole truth, that wasn't the point.
The point was- regardless of whether or not he has ever pulled the trigger and his exaggerated stories, he still deserves a certain amount of gratitude and respect just for being a Marine, deployed- out there defending perhaps a slightly more honests american ability to sit on the couch and watch american idol.
Most grunts I know are quite dissapointed when they come to face the fact that they don't get the opprotunity to do what they or america expects them to, and a few exaggerate to compensate. Is that right? NO. But if you're not out there, you should be so damned grateful that he did any kind of deployment for you, and happy he's just coming home in one piece.



I do not agree. But that aside...this wouldn't be the Rachel I know from 1/6 i think it was? Or maybe 2/2? The Rachel I know through eric peterson sgt type.

if it is what's goin on man?


No, not her, sorry.
 
Posts: 28 | Registered: Tue 06 May 2008Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
I was in AL Qaim in 2006 and it was a blast. I'm former Army but if anything the living conditions there are probably the worst thing now(unless they have gotten better)
 
Posts: 2046 | Registered: Tue 12 February 2008Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Of course his tall tales aren't respectable, and his exagerations are like fishing stories.


I disagree completely. There is a big difference between some irrelevant fishing story and exaggerating his military exploits. Once he gets away with a few fibs about high-speed units he’s in and combat he never saw, he’ll stretch them further and start wearing medals he didn’t earn as well.

quote:
The point was- regardless of whether or not he has ever pulled the trigger and his exaggerated stories, he still deserves a certain amount of gratitude and respect just for being a Marine, deployed-



He should be proud of his service at face value. Should we all be blind to the fact that he’s a liar, insulting our intelligence and making himself and the Marine Corps look pretty stupid? What about all of the Marines who really did see combat? What about the Marines who didn’t see combat and are honest about it?

By the way, what is your MOS?
 
Posts: 1346 | Registered: Sat 23 September 2000Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by anywherealwaysready:
quote:
Originally posted by followmetolive:
quote:
Originally posted by anywherealwaysready:
Of course his tall tales aren't respectable, and his exagerations are like fishing stories. I never said he was telling the whole truth, that wasn't the point.
The point was- regardless of whether or not he has ever pulled the trigger and his exaggerated stories, he still deserves a certain amount of gratitude and respect just for being a Marine, deployed- out there defending perhaps a slightly more honests american ability to sit on the couch and watch american idol.
Most grunts I know are quite dissapointed when they come to face the fact that they don't get the opprotunity to do what they or america expects them to, and a few exaggerate to compensate. Is that right? NO. But if you're not out there, you should be so damned grateful that he did any kind of deployment for you, and happy he's just coming home in one piece.



I do not agree. But that aside...this wouldn't be the Rachel I know from 1/6 i think it was? Or maybe 2/2? The Rachel I know through eric peterson sgt type.

if it is what's goin on man?


No, not her, sorry.


Rachel was a guy...it was his last name...

that was what I saw on your profile my bad
 
Posts: 89 | Registered: Fri 30 March 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Bri6366:
quote:
Of course his tall tales aren't respectable, and his exagerations are like fishing stories.


I disagree completely. There is a big difference between some irrelevant fishing story and exaggerating his military exploits. Once he gets away with a few fibs about high-speed units he’s in and combat he never saw, he’ll stretch them further and start wearing medals he didn’t earn as well.

quote:
The point was- regardless of whether or not he has ever pulled the trigger and his exaggerated stories, he still deserves a certain amount of gratitude and respect just for being a Marine, deployed-



He should be proud of his service at face value. Should we all be blind to the fact that he’s a liar, insulting our intelligence and making himself and the Marine Corps look pretty stupid? What about all of the Marines who really did see combat? What about the Marines who didn’t see combat and are honest about it?

By the way, what is your MOS?



I know the name Golder and you look familar.

The name Dugger ring a bell?
 
Posts: 89 | Registered: Fri 30 March 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
I know the name Golder and you look familar.

The name Dugger ring a bell?



Sorry, doesn't ring a bell. I've been out for 20 years now. Are you with 6th Marines now?
 
Posts: 1346 | Registered: Sat 23 September 2000Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
 Previous Topic | Next Topic powered by eve community  
 

Military.com    Military.com Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  Marine Corps Discussions  Hop To Forums  USMC Infantry    Anyone back from al Qaim,Iraq 2007

© 2008 Military Advantage, Inc.