Check These Out: Buddy Finder | Videos | SpouseBUZZ | My Friend Network | News | Military Equipment


Military.com    Military.com Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  Coast Guard Discussions  Hop To Forums  The Soapbox    Candidate For Waterboarding?
Page 1 2 3 4 
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
  Login/Join 
Member
Posted
His (al-Masri) capture has not been confirmed yet. I would consider him a HVT. If his capture is true....is he a candidate for waterboarding? Yes??? No???



http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,354666,00.html

quote:
U.S. Military Unable to Confirm Capture of Al Qaeda Leader in Iraq
Friday, May 09, 2008


Abu Ayyub al-Masri
BAGHDAD — The U.S. military on Friday said there were "no operational reports" so far to confirm Iraqi government reports that the leader of Al Qaeda in Iraq has been arrested.

Iraqi authorities on Thursday said Iraqi police commandos captured the leader of Al Qaeda in Iraq in a raid in the northern city of Mosul, in what if confirmed would be significant blow to the Sunni insurgency in its last urban stronghold.

Early Friday, however, the U.S. military said there were "no operational reports" to confirm that Abu Ayyub al-Masri — also known as Abu Hamza al-Muhajir — was captured. News of the reported capture was trumpeted by Iraqi state television and numerous Iraqi government and provincial officials.

Iraqi Defense Ministry spokesman Mohammed al-Askari said late Thursday that the arrest was made in Mosul, where insurgents have sought to establish a foothold after being widely uprooted from Baghdad and surrounding areas last year.

Interior Ministry spokesman Maj. Gen. Abdul-Karim Khalaf said the arrest occurred "at midnight and during the primary investigations he admitted that he is Abu Hamza Al-Muhajir."

There have been false alarms in the past about al-Masri. At least twice — in 2006 and May 2007 — reports circulated that al-Masri was dead, but they were later proved wrong.

Khalaf told the Iraqi state television that al-Masri was arrested during a police raid in Mosul, but gave no other details. "Now a broader investigation of him is being conducted," he said.

Mosul was considered the last important urban staging ground for Al Qaeda in Iraqi and allied groups after losing strongholds in Baghdad and other areas during the U.S. troop "surge" last year.

In January, Iraq's prime minister Nouri al-Maliki promised his military were preparing for a "decisive" showdown with insurgents in Mosul, about 225 miles northwest of Baghdad. But no major offensives have been mounted even as Al Qaeda in Iraq tried to exert its influence in Iraq's third-largest city through attacks and intimidation.

Al-Masri is a prized target for Iraqi commanders, who have led operations in the Mosul area and have sought to counter worries that Iraqi forces lack the training and discipline to wage a head-on fight against insurgents.

However, Al Qaeda in Iraq has maintained its long-term ability to wage suicide attacks and other strikes even after the capture and deaths of its leaders. Al-Masri took over Al Qaeda in Iraq after its leader, Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, was killed June 7, 2006 in a U.S. airstrike northeast of Baghdad.

The pace of insurgent attacks continued unabated as al-Masri took charge.

Al-Masri has been in contact with some of bin Laden's top lieutenants.

U.S. officials said al-Masri — whose name means "The Egyptian" in Arabic — joined Al Qaeda camps in Afghanistan in the late 1990s and trained as a car bombing expert before traveling to Iraq after the U.S.-led invasion in 2003.

The U.S. military also described al-Masri as a previous member of the extremist Islamic Jihad in Egypt and a protege of Ayman al-Zawahri, who became bin Laden's No. 2 after the group joined with Al Qaeda in 1998.

The Islamic State of Iraq, an umbrella organization that includes Al Qaeda in Iraq, last year announced an "Islamic Cabinet" for Iraq and named al-Masri as "minister of war." The U.S. military had put a $5 million bounty for al-Masri.

Meanwhile, the U.S. military on Friday said U.S. soldiers killed six Shiite extremists, who attacked U.S. forces with shoulder fired rockets and small arms, in several clashes in Baghdad's Shiite militia stronghold of Sadr City on Thursday.

The reported arrest of al-Masri has also turned attention back to the Sunni insurgency after weeks of battles with Shiite militias.

On Thursday, government envoys set strict demands for Shiite militias to end their battles against U.S.-led forces in Baghdad. But it was unlikely that militiamen would abide by the government conditions to lay down their arms.

But the government outreach to representatives of anti-American cleric Muqtada al-Sadr — who controls the powerful Mahdi Army militia — underscored the worries about a mounting humanitarian and political crises for Iraq's leadership if the fighting spreads.

Thousands of civilians already have fled their homes in Sadr City — home to nearly 40 percent of Baghdad's population — and aid groups say some areas are desperately short of food and medicine after seven weeks of street battles.

The latest conflict flared in late March after Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki ordered a crackdown on armed Shiite factions in the southern city of Basra, the nation's second-largest urban area. Mahdi fighters quickly rose up in Basra and Sadr City, their stronghold in Baghdad.
 
Posts: 1653 | Registered: Sat 12 January 2002Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Experienced Member
Picture of Hooligan1790
Posted Hide Post
According to U.S. sources they don't have him.
 
Posts: 6184 | Registered: Sun 22 May 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
Nobody should be a "candidate for water boarding". You're an idiot.
 
Posts: 582 | Registered: Fri 27 August 2004Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
A candidate for water boarding? Only if you want to violate that pesky little international agreement called United Nations Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment. Oh, I forgot. The right wing thinks that water boarding isn't torture. Well if it's not torture, then why would it be used?
 
Posts: 1047 | Registered: Fri 06 October 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Highly Experienced Member
Posted Hide Post
No....We should ask him if he could meet at a Holiday Inn Express....buy him a breakfast at Marie Collanders and apologize to him for our nations mistakes. Then send him off with a handshake and respectfully ask him if he would stop killing innocents to obtain his desires.
 
Posts: 8358 | Registered: Fri 20 April 2001Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
scrounge,

Please spar us the old and tired, and very, very typical, right wing response. No one here is saying that we should apologize or treat this guy (if he's even captured) as if he were a respectful citizen. What's we're saying is that torture is wrong, immoral, and illegal. Deal with it.
 
Posts: 1047 | Registered: Fri 06 October 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Highly Experienced Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by FourString:
scrounge,

Please spar us the old and tired, and very, very typical, right wing response. No one here is saying that we should apologize or treat this guy (if he's even captured) as if he were a respectful citizen. What's we're saying is that torture is wrong, immoral, and illegal. Deal with it.


No...He has rights too..He's earned his place at the top he should be treated like a King!

Now if he was the real enemy, you know a conservsative republican trying to protect the nations best interests, hang 'em up by his thumbs!
 
Posts: 8358 | Registered: Fri 20 April 2001Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
scrounge, Dont we want our country to be better than the people we are fighting? We are a civilized society. You seem to believe in this country, as do I. Torture is what separates's us from them. We are not barbaric, we do not torture so we are looked up to.
 
Posts: 582 | Registered: Fri 27 August 2004Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Highly Experienced Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by FrankieFunk:
scrounge, Dont we want our country to be better than the people we are fighting? We are a civilized society. You seem to believe in this country, as do I. Torture is what separates's us from them. We are not barbaric, we do not torture so we are looked up to.


We are better...But to the liberal apologist/ appeaser, we're not better unless we are the most popular too! We must first seek the UN's approval, check in with Germany and France and be sure that we are appealing to their softer gentler (food for oil) side....

Torture is not what seperates us, Freedom is what seperates us, Your ability to piss all over those that are trying to prtotect you ..is what seperates us...Usery is another large seperation. They stand united...we whine and moan....
 
Posts: 8358 | Registered: Fri 20 April 2001Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by scrounge:
quote:
Originally posted by FourString:
scrounge,

Please spar us the old and tired, and very, very typical, right wing response. No one here is saying that we should apologize or treat this guy (if he's even captured) as if he were a respectful citizen. What's we're saying is that torture is wrong, immoral, and illegal. Deal with it.


No...He has rights too..He's earned his place at the top he should be treated like a King!

Now if he was the real enemy, you know a conservsative republican trying to protect the nations best interests, hang 'em up by his thumbs!


Who would Jesus hang by his thumbs (or water board)?

Once again you show that you must take things to a silly extreme every time. No one is saying he should be treated like a king. We're just saying that torturing him would violate the international law our representative government has seen fit to abide by. Is that really hard for you to understand?
 
Posts: 1047 | Registered: Fri 06 October 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
Frankie,

You're speaking logic and reason to someone who deals in hyperbole and emtremes.
 
Posts: 1047 | Registered: Fri 06 October 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by FrankieFunk:
Nobody should be a "candidate for water boarding". You're an idiot.


Idiot??? Now my feelings are hurt! Roll Eyes

One first has to consider waterboarding torture That of course depends on who you ask. There are "experts" on both sides who could present a sound argument either way.

Regardless.....if this HVT has intel that will save the lives of our soldiers or allies, it has to be on the table.
 
Posts: 1653 | Registered: Sat 12 January 2002Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by scrounge:
quote:
Originally posted by FrankieFunk:
scrounge, Dont we want our country to be better than the people we are fighting? We are a civilized society. You seem to believe in this country, as do I. Torture is what separates's us from them. We are not barbaric, we do not torture so we are looked up to.


We are better...But to the liberal apologist/ appeaser, we're not better unless we are the most popular too! We must first seek the UN's approval, check in with Germany and France and be sure that we are appealing to their softer gentler (food for oil) side....

Torture is not what seperates us, Freedom is what seperates us, Your ability to piss all over those that are trying to prtotect you ..is what seperates us...Usery is another large seperation. They stand united...we whine and moan....


Scrounge, You didn't answer my question. Do you think torture makes us as barbaric as let say Iran that often tortures prisoners?
 
Posts: 582 | Registered: Fri 27 August 2004Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Who would Jesus hang by his thumbs (or water board)?


We don't have to worry about that in the U.S. anymore as the left is trying to run Jesus out of the country too. The only time the left envokes the name of Jesus is to make a point. Shameful! Mad
 
Posts: 1266 | Registered: Mon 04 June 2001Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Highly Experienced Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by FourString:
quote:
Originally posted by scrounge:
quote:
Originally posted by FourString:
scrounge,

Please spar us the old and tired, and very, very typical, right wing response. No one here is saying that we should apologize or treat this guy (if he's even captured) as if he were a respectful citizen. What's we're saying is that torture is wrong, immoral, and illegal. Deal with it.


No...He has rights too..He's earned his place at the top he should be treated like a King!

Now if he was the real enemy, you know a conservsative republican trying to protect the nations best interests, hang 'em up by his thumbs!


Who would Jesus hang by his thumbs (or water board)?

Once again you show that you must take things to a silly extreme every time. No one is saying he should be treated like a king. We're just saying that torturing him would violate the international law our representative government has seen fit to abide by. Is that really hard for you to understand?


If you are going to bring Jesus into this...are you bringing in the Hollywood version or the one that leveled Babel? How about the one that said, let the dead bury the dead? How about the one that went into the temple and threw everyone out? How about the one that took King David's son and from him because of his adultry and murderous ways?

If you don't understand beyond hollywood's version don't try to use it for rationalization purposes...There is a time for peace and a time for war. There are consequences for ones actions, even with forgiveness.

About waterboarding....In the scale of things, speak about seperation...we worry about waterboarding, they rejoice over beheading and blowing up innocents.
 
Posts: 8358 | Registered: Fri 20 April 2001Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Mazski9:
quote:
Who would Jesus hang by his thumbs (or water board)?


We don't have to worry about that in the U.S. anymore as the left is trying to run Jesus out of the country too. The only time the left envokes the name of Jesus is to make a point. Shameful! Mad


The "left" is not trying to run Jesus out of the country. I know it's a strange concept but some people believe that religion should be kept in the home and the church, and never in school or government. Its called separation of church and state
 
Posts: 582 | Registered: Fri 27 August 2004Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Highly Experienced Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by FrankieFunk:
quote:
Originally posted by Mazski9:
quote:
Who would Jesus hang by his thumbs (or water board)?


We don't have to worry about that in the U.S. anymore as the left is trying to run Jesus out of the country too. The only time the left envokes the name of Jesus is to make a point. Shameful! Mad


The "left" is not trying to run Jesus out of the country. I know it's a strange concept but some people believe that religion should be kept in the home and the church, and never in school or government. Its called separation of church and state


Again the liberals take Jefferesons letter out of context.

Do you even know why he wrote that letter? Do you know what the intent in the letter is about?
 
Posts: 8358 | Registered: Fri 20 April 2001Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Mazski9:
quote:
Who would Jesus hang by his thumbs (or water board)?


We don't have to worry about that in the U.S. anymore as the left is trying to run Jesus out of the country too. The only time the left envokes the name of Jesus is to make a point. Shameful! Mad


I got a good laugh out of that one. "Run Jesus out of the country"? This shows just how out of touch certain people really are. Jesus can't be "run out of the country" because he knows no nation. He lives in peoples' hearts and he preaches love and compassion. I think the Old Testament is better suited for war mongers.
 
Posts: 1047 | Registered: Fri 06 October 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
scrounge,

So Jesus through everyone out of the temple? So what? Did he follow that up by simulating the drowning of the people he was pissed at? Did he go futher than just getting angry and begin to torture and kill people?

As for your last comment, what's your point? The Nazis rejoiced in mass murder and genocide. Does that give the U.S. the right to engage in barbaric behaviour as well?

You can respond if you want, but "debating" with you is useless. You don't listen, and just like Hannity and Savage, you creat your own argument that has nothing to do with what was originally stated.

Have a nice day.
 
Posts: 1047 | Registered: Fri 06 October 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
Member
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by scrounge:
quote:
Originally posted by FrankieFunk:
quote:
Originally posted by Mazski9:
quote:
Who would Jesus hang by his thumbs (or water board)?


We don't have to worry about that in the U.S. anymore as the left is trying to run Jesus out of the country too. The only time the left envokes the name of Jesus is to make a point. Shameful! Mad


The "left" is not trying to run Jesus out of the country. I know it's a strange concept but some people believe that religion should be kept in the home and the church, and never in school or government. Its called separation of church and state


Again the liberals take Jefferesons letter out of context.

Do you even know why he wrote that letter? Do you know what the intent in the letter is about?


So scrounge if we allow religion in public school and government. Which religion should it be? How about every religion even one I just made up where everyone worships cactus.
 
Posts: 582 | Registered: Fri 27 August 2004Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete Message
 Previous Topic | Next Topic powered by eve community Page 1 2 3 4  
 

Military.com    Military.com Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  Coast Guard Discussions  Hop To Forums  The Soapbox    Candidate For Waterboarding?

© 2008 Military Advantage, Inc.